LITERACY · PARENTS
Your Child's Literacy Isn't Failing. It Was Never the Priority.
Governments on both sides of the Atlantic have declared literacy a crisis. But when you look at what schools were actually designed to measure, and what reading means for a child's whole life, something far more uncomfortable becomes clear.
Tirzah Elese Bagnulo
Founder & CEO, ExelAcademy · 10 min read

Let's Start With the Numbers, Because They're Staggering
The National Literacy Trust surveys more than 114,000 children and young people across the UK every year. Their 2025 data should have made the front pages for a month. Just one in three children aged 8 to 18 said they enjoyed reading in their free time, th e lowest level since the survey began in 2005. Fewer than one in five read anything daily.
In the United States, the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) found that only 31% of fourth-graders read at a proficient level, and 40% scored below even the basic level. And one of the most quietly devastating findings in education research comes from a landmark study by Connie Juel: a child who is struggling to read at the end of first grade has an 88% chance of still struggling by fourth grade.
Early reading difficulty is not a phase. For most children who don't receive targeted, intensive support, it becomes a permanent ceiling.
These are not numbers about one struggling school or one deprived neighbourhood. These are system-wide outcomes. And they are getting worse, not better, despite decades of intervention programmes, government initiatives and well-meaning campaigns.
So Why Is This Happening?
The answers on offer are causes we have discussed for years: screen time, social media, the decline of bedtime reading, underfunded school libraries, teacher workload, post-pandemic catch-up. All of these are real. All of them contribute.
Yet there is an unspoken structural point I want to address. Schools were not built to produce deep readers. They were built to produce functional workers: people who could follow instructions, pass tests and be ranked against each other in a way that made allocation decisions easy. Reading, in that framework, is a skill. A tool. A means to another end. The idea of reading as intrinsic pleasure, as the gateway to imagination and intellectual depth, as one of the most powerful cognitive tools a human being can develop, was never the system's concern.
My son spent his entire childhood with a book, comic or novel in his hands. Literature was not something he did. It was something he was. And yet he dreaded English class. Not occasionally. Consistently, year after year, the subject he loved most outside school became the one he resisted most inside it. He even wrote his final-year "rant paper" under the title "Who the F$%k Understands Shakespeare?"
The same happened with Geography. His father is obsessed with maps: the kind of person who can trace a border and tell you why it was drawn that way, what war caused it, and what it costs the people who live on either side of it. We spent whatever spare money we had taking our children around the world. We stood in the ruins of ancient civilisations, traced rivers on real maps, and held artefacts older than the countries that now claimed them. And Geography was his worst grade and his most dreaded lesson.
I used to think this was coincidence, or just one disappointing teacher. Now I understand it is the system working exactly as designed. Traditional education was never built to inspire a love of a subject or to produce genuine depth within it. It was built to produce a grade: a number that proves your worth to the next institution that needs to sort you.
THE RESEARCH SAYS
National Literacy Trust research has found again and again that children who enjoy reading score significantly higher on reading assessments than those who don't. The relationship runs both ways: better readers enjoy reading more, and children who read for pleasure become better readers faster.
Enjoyment is not a nice-to-have. It is the engine. And schools, for the most part, have systematically dismantled it.
How Schools Kill Reading: Slowly, and With Good Intentions
Think about how reading is experienced in most schools. A text is assigned. Children read it, or are read to. Comprehension questions are answered. Vocabulary is tested. The passage is annotated. There is a right way to have responded to this text, and the child is assessed on how close they came to it.
And then we wonder why only one in three children say they enjoy reading in their free time.
The things that make reading joyful (choice, pace, getting lost in a world, reading for reasons that matter to you) are almost entirely absent from the classroom reading experience. What remains is compliance. And compliance, as every parent of a twelve-year-old knows, is not a sustainable foundation for a lifelong habit.
The question is not what reading skills children lack. It is what conditions produce readers, and whether schools create those conditions or destroy them.
This is especially acute for boys. The National Literacy Trust's 2025 data shows the steepest drop in reading enjoyment among boys aged 11 to 16, with the gender gap in daily reading now at its widest since 2023. The system that most struggles to engage boys through reading, asking them to annotate literary passages and answer comprehension questions about feelings, is the system we are now calling a crisis.
The human brain was not built for silence. It grows with a story. For tens of thousands of years, before schools, before curricula, before standardised tests, communities gathered around fires and passed on knowledge, culture and identity through narrative. The story was not entertainment. It was the architecture of civilisation. The brain did not merely enjoy a story. It required it. And that requirement has not changed.
What has changed is where we go to satisfy it. Strip a child of the habit of reading, remove the patience and deep absorption a book demands, and the brain does not go quiet. It goes looking. And it finds exactly what it was designed to respond to: a feed engineered by some of the most sophisticated behavioural science on earth to deliver story, novelty and social signal in the most frictionless form ever created.
The scroll is not a failure of willpower. It is a completely rational response by a story-hungry brain to an environment that has failed to give it anything better. We did not lose a generation of readers to screens. We lost them first to classrooms that made reading feel like compliance, and the screens were simply waiting.
The Class Dimension
One detail in the data deserves its own headline. In the UK, Free School Meals are the standard marker of a low-income household. Children receiving them are less likely to read daily than their peers. And one in six of them does not own a single book of their own, compared with one in eleven of their better-off classmates.
The literacy gap is not evenly distributed. It is concentrated, predictably and shamefully, among the children who were already most disadvantaged. Which means the system that was supposed to be the great equaliser (free, compulsory, universal education) is in practice deepening the divide it was meant to close.
Parents who grew up with literacy around them compensate. They buy books. They read aloud. They model reading. They take children to libraries and bookshops and talk about what they're reading over dinner. Researchers have long found that the number of books in a childhood home is one of the strongest predictors of how far a child goes in education. The child whose parent works two jobs and comes home exhausted often doesn't have that environment, and the parent may never have had it to pass on.
And school, increasingly, is not filling that gap.
What Actually Builds Readers
The research is remarkably clear on this. Children become readers through three things:
- Access to books that interest them, not books chosen for them by curriculum committees.
- Time to read without assessment attached.
- Adults who read, and who talk about reading with genuine enthusiasm.
None of this requires a government initiative, a new curriculum framework or another literacy strategy. It requires something far simpler and far more radical: stepping back. Letting a child sit with a book for no other reason than the pleasure of it. No comprehension questions at the end. No vocabulary test on Friday. No annotation. Just the oldest human experience there is: a story, and a mind willing to disappear into it.
And this matters even more right now, because AI will do the annotation. AI will dissect the text, identify the metaphors, trace the thematic arc and produce the kind of close literary analysis that currently fills much of a GCSE English course (the exams English students sit at 16) or a high school English class. It will do it faster, and often with more nuance, than most of us ever could. The mechanical comprehension tasks, the formulaic essay structures, the colour-coded highlighting: these are not the future of literacy. They are its past.
What AI cannot replicate is a child who has fallen in love with words. Who has lived inside a story long enough to understand something true about being human. Who has the emotional vocabulary, the imaginative depth and the genuine hunger for narrative that only comes from a childhood spent actually reading.
That is what we are protecting. Not the test score. The reader.
At ExelAcademy, we believe the most powerful thing you can do for a young person's relationship with language is to give them authorship over it. Through ExelQuests™, young people don't just consume stories; they build them. They become authors, crafting their own narratives, sharing them in ways that feel meaningful to them, and discovering that their voice is worth something. They read not to annotate, but to research: to find the information, ideas and details that will make their own work richer and truer. Reading becomes purposeful in the deepest sense: not a task to complete, but a tool to think with, create with and, eventually, lead with.
What Parents Can Do, Starting Today
If you are reading this as a parent, here is the most useful thing you can hear: the system is very unlikely to fix this for your child. Not because the people in it don't care, but because its incentives don't reward the things that build readers.
What actually works is within your reach, whatever school your child attends:
- Give them access to books they choose. Not books you think they should read. Not age-appropriate lists from school. Books they pick up and can't put down, whether that's graphic novels, thrillers, football biographies or the most absurd comedies they can find. When a child is still becoming a reader, volume matters far more than quality. The taste develops. The habit has to come first.
- Read yourself, visibly and with pleasure. Talk about what you're reading. Make it normal, not educational.
- If your child is struggling with decoding and fluency, get them targeted help now. Not next term. That 88% figure is real. The window for intervention is short.
2026 is the UK's National Year of Reading. It will come and go. The literacy statistics will be reported, wrung over, answered with new policies, and largely unchanged. That has been the rhythm of education reform for thirty years.
What will change outcomes for individual children is parents who understand what's actually happening, who don't wait for the system to catch up, and who decide that reading (real reading, chosen reading, joyful reading) is something they will build into their child's life, whatever the curriculum demands.
A child who loves to read is not just ahead in English. They are ahead in everything: in empathy, in vocabulary, in the ability to hold complex ideas, in the capacity to think before speaking, and in the sheer scope of the inner world they bring to every experience. That is not an accident. That is what reading does. And it is far too important to leave to a system that was never really built to deliver it.

About Tirzah
Tirzah Elese Bagnulo is Founder and CEO of ExelAcademy, a human-led, AI-enabled online school. She brings more than three decades of teaching and educational transformation, fifteen years of studying how the brain learns, and is the author of The Learning Commitment. Tirzah Talks is where she thinks out loud about what education is for, now that AI can do so much of what it once focused on.
Sources & further reading (6)+
- National Literacy Trust. Children and young people's reading in 2025 (114,970 respondents aged 5 to 18).
- National Literacy Trust. 1 in 6 disadvantaged children in the UK don't own a single book (2025).
- National Center for Education Statistics. NAEP 2024 Reading: Grade 4 national results (Nation's Report Card).
- Juel, C. (1988). Learning to read and write: a longitudinal study of 54 children from first through fourth grades. Journal of Educational Psychology, 80(4).
- Evans, M. D. R., Kelley, J., Sikora, J. and Treiman, D. J. (2010). Family scholarly culture and educational success: books and schooling in 27 nations. Research in Social Stratification and Mobility.
- University of Birmingham. 2026 Year of Reading: the reduction in children and young people reading is a social justice issue (2025).
More Tirzah Talks
Find more blogs in Tirzah's Homeschool Network
Join the community for new Tirzah Talks posts, ready-to-use project-based learning, and a place to share your thoughts with families who believe education can be better.


