US EDITION · SOCIAL MEDIA · OPINION
America Is Banning the Screen. Are We Skipping the Lesson?
State by state, and now in Congress, America is moving to keep kids off social media. Here's the conversation we might be choosing not to have.
Tirzah Elese Bagnulo
Founder & CEO, ExelAcademy · 8 min read

On October 14, a federal appeals court ruled that Florida can enforce its law keeping children off social media. Under HB 3, under-14s can't hold accounts on platforms built around addictive features like infinite scroll, and 14 and 15-year-olds need a parent's permission. The law had been blocked since June 2025. Now it can go ahead.
Florida isn't alone. By late 2025, at least eight states (Arkansas, California, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, Ohio and Tennessee) had passed laws banning or restricting minors' social media accounts. Virginia tried to limit under-16s to one hour a day. Many of these laws are tied up in court on First Amendment grounds, and some have been struck down entirely. In Washington, a bipartisan House bill would set a national minimum age of 16, while the Kids Online Safety Act remains stalled in the Senate.
And the rest of the world is moving too. Australia's under-16 ban has been in force since December 2025. The UK has announced its own, aiming for spring 2027.
For many parents, all of this will land as relief. For others, as overreach. I find myself somewhere more uncomfortable than either: genuinely undecided, and increasingly convinced that the version of this debate playing out in the headlines is missing its most important question.
So let's actually sit with this. All of it.
The Case for the Ban Is Real
Start with what we know. The mental health data behind these laws isn't abstract. In the CDC's most recent national survey, 40% of high school students said they had felt persistently sad or hopeless, and among girls it was 53%. That is slightly better than 2021, but still a generation in distress. In 2023, the US Surgeon General warned that teens who spend more than three hours a day on social media face double the risk of depression and anxiety symptoms. The average American teenager spends nearly five.
Then there's the neuroscience. Adolescent brains are still building the architecture for impulse control, delayed gratification and emotional regulation, precisely while platforms are engineered, with enormous commercial sophistication, to exploit the gaps in that architecture. Infinite scroll, variable reward schedules, social comparison loops: these aren't accidents of design. If we wouldn't let a 13-year-old walk into a casino, the argument goes, why are we comfortable handing them a device built on similar principles?
There's also something to be said for collective standards. America sets the drinking age at 21. It doesn't stop every 19-year-old getting hold of a beer, but it sets a societal floor. Supporters of these laws make the same argument: a line in the sand, even an imperfect one, is not nothing.
But Is a Line in the Sand the Same as a Lesson Learned?
Here's where I start to feel less settled. And it's America's own history that gives me pause.
Prohibition didn't eliminate alcohol. From 1920 to 1933 it removed drinking from regulated, visible, socially mediated settings and pushed it into speakeasies and back rooms, with consequences that took decades to unwind. The lesson most historians draw isn't simply "banning things doesn't work." It's something more specific:
When you remove something from view rather than changing our relationship to it, you don't remove the behavior. You remove your ability to influence it.
Early evidence from Australia is already raising this question. Research from the UK's Molly Rose Foundation found that 61% of Australian 12 to 15-year-olds who had accounts before the ban still have access to at least one. Half said the ban had made no difference to their safety online, and 14% said it made them feel less safe.
And in the US there's a further twist. With so many state laws blocked or delayed in the courts, the ban many parents are waiting for may arrive slowly, unevenly, or not at all. Meanwhile, their children are online right now. And the next frontier has already arrived: nearly two in three American teens now talk to AI chatbots, and almost none of these laws were written with that in mind.
The Live Teaching Moment We Might Be Removing
This is the part I keep returning to.
These platforms, these algorithms, these dopamine loops are not going away. The 16-year-old handed an account on their birthday walks into exactly the same attention economy as the 15-year-old who wasn't allowed one. Nothing about the tools will have changed. What might have changed is whether anyone ever sat with that young person, in real time, while it was actually happening to them, and asked: What just happened in your brain there? Why did that post make you feel that way? What is it about that comment that landed so hard?
Those conversations are very hard to have after the event, or in theory, or about a platform a young person has never used. They are far easier, and arguably only really possible, in the moment, while the feed is still open on the phone in their hand.
If I were parenting teenagers again today (and I say this with real humility, because the landscape now is so much more complex than it was even eight years ago), I think I'd want to have a very different kind of conversation. Not "get off your phone," but: Let's look at what came up on your feed today. How did that make you feel? Why do you think a stranger's comment about how you look had that effect on you? What would it feel like to scroll past that, rather than stay on it?
That's not permissiveness. It's a different kind of safeguarding: one based on building the internal compass, rather than relying only on the external fence.
Two Things Can Be True
Perhaps the honest position is that the ban and the missing conversation aren't actually in competition. They could be companions. A ban buys time and sets a floor. But a floor isn't a curriculum. If we use the years before 16 purely as years of absence, rather than years of preparation, we may simply be postponing the moment of first contact to an age where the supervision, the modeling and the "let's look at this together" conversations are far less likely to happen at all.
This is something we think about often at ExelAcademy. Not as an argument against these laws, but as a question about what fills the space alongside them. Understanding your own attention, your own emotional responses, your own relationship to validation and feedback: these are forms of literacy as real as reading or math. And they are learned best in context, not in the abstract.
Over to You
I don't think this is a debate with a clean answer, and I'm wary of anyone, myself included, who claims certainty either way.
So I'd genuinely like to know what you think. If you're a parent, a teacher, or someone who remembers what it was like to be 14 with a phone in your pocket:
Does the ban feel like protection, or like postponement?
And if you could sit with a teenager today while their feed was open in front of them, what's the first question you'd actually ask them?

About Tirzah
Tirzah Elese Bagnulo is Founder and CEO of ExelAcademy, a human-led, AI-enabled online school. She brings more than three decades of teaching and educational transformation, fifteen years of studying how the brain learns, and is the author of The Learning Commitment. Tirzah Talks is where she thinks out loud about what education is for, now that AI can do so much of what it once focused on.
Sources & further reading (9)+
- WCTV. Florida law banning social media for kids can be enforced, appeals court says (11th Circuit ruling, 14 October 2026).
- MultiState. Eight states enact minor social media bans despite court fights (October 2025).
- DLA Piper. Virginia's social media time-limit law for minors blocked (NetChoice v. Jones, February 2026).
- Roll Call. Houchin looks to push kids social media ban in lame duck (October 2026; KOSA and KIDS Act status).
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Youth Risk Behavior Survey (2023 data).
- Office of the US Surgeon General. Social Media and Youth Mental Health advisory (2023).
- Gallup. Teens Spend Average of 4.8 Hours on Social Media Per Day (2023).
- Pew Research Center. Teens, Social Media and AI Chatbots 2025 (December 2025).
- Molly Rose Foundation and YouthInsight. More than 60% of Australian children still using social media despite ban for under-16s.
More from Tirzah Talks
More Tirzah Talks
Find more blogs in Tirzah's Homeschool Network
Join the community for new Tirzah Talks posts, ready-to-use project-based learning, and a place to share your thoughts with families who believe education can be better.


